Pierwsze oceny Red Dead Redemption 2 (średnia 97%):
IGN Italy - 100 / 100
ZTGD - 100 / 100
AusGamers - 100 / 100
Areajugones - 100 / 100
Stevivor - 100 / 100
The Digital Fix - 100 / 100
GameZone - 100 / 100
TrueAchievements - 100 / 100
God is a Geek - 100 / 100
Game Debate - 100 / 100
Telegraph - 100 / 100
Digital Chumps - 100 / 100
PlayStation LifeStyle - 100 / 100
GameSpew - 100 / 100
Game Revolution - 100 / 100
Guardian - 100 / 100
Easy Allies - 100 / 100
IGN - 100 / 100
Windows Central - 100 / 100
Push Square - 100 / 100
DualShockers - 100 / 100
Press Start - 100 / 100
Twinfinite - 100 / 100
Gameblog - 100 / 100
GamesRadar+ - 100 / 100
COGconnected - 100 / 100
Digital Trends - 100 / 100
TheSixthAxis - 100 / 100
We Got This Covered - 100 / 100
PlayStation Universe - 100 / 100
Game Informer - 100 / 100
Game Informer - 100 / 100
Attack of the Fanboy - 100 / 100
GamingTrend - 100 / 100
Gaming Nexus - 100 / 100
IGN Spain - 100 / 100
Generación Xbox - 100 / 100
Gamersky - 100 / 100
Hobby Consolas - 99 / 100
Wccftech - 97 / 100
GamePro - 96 / 100
Critical Hit - 95 / 100
Destructoid - 95 / 100
CGMagazine - 95 / 100
Gameplanet - 95 / 100
Xbox Achievements - 95 / 100
Worth Playing - 90 / 100
Gamers Heroes - 90 / 100
VideoGamer - 90 / 100
Metro GameCentral - 90 / 100
Cubed3 - 90 / 100
Shacknews - 90 / 100
Daily Dot - 90 / 100
Forbes - 90 / 100
USgamer - 90 / 100
GameSpot - 90 / 100
New Game Network - 82 / 100